Skip to main content

issue #316 of brennan.day

An Open Apology to Householder Karl

I owe Householder Karl an apology. On Nov. 20th, 2026 at 6:27 PM UTC, I wrote him an email that was rude and insulting which I had no right to send. He published our exchange (archived), which was in his right. He showed a photo of me, and that's fine. I am not an anonymous blogger, and I won't run away from who I am or what I do. That's why I'm writing this out.

I want to offer some context, none of which changes how I was the one out of line.

My frustration began with a post of his called "Mental" (archived):

Mental (2026-09-26 13:48)

Everyone is scrambling to find a place on the spectrum. They plant their flag with stupid smiles and parade their mundane neuroses around as autism. Look at my quirky mental illness. The whimsy of misfiring synapses. The romance of chemical imbalances.

Shut the fuck up. You don’t need a semicolon tattoo or an awareness lanyard so people on the bus can force the smile usually reserved for three-legged dogs and deformed babies. Being bothered by loud noises is not a personality.

Desperate for an identity, you force yourself into a minority. Find a hobby and embrace the fact that you’re fundamentally unimpressive, a boring wage slave who will perish in obscurity like the rest of us.

Too bad that isn’t enough for you, but no one cares. Your life is the "–" carved on granite between your birth year and a rapidly approaching date with death.

I think this post is incredibly ableist and stigmatizing, and reads as reactionary anti-mental health rhetoric. But I didn't do anything about it at the time, I shrugged and moved on. It was only a few days ago I decided to revisit Karl's blog again and found that there had been a significant tonal shift, this was now a guy blogging with far more consideration and openness, all the edginess of the original posts smoothed out and gone. He wrote about being a dad and having a kid, and I wrote my email because of that. Because of how I felt about a parent having these kinds of opinions and understandings of mental health. But none of that gives cause or justification for what I wrote.

Now, let's go back in time a bit. Right before Unstory—who I've written about before—deleted his blog, his final entry was this:

I was robbed (2026-09-26 16:15)

Somebody took my proprietary CSS and made a website with it. I investigated. His name is Karl and he lives at:

https://householderkarl.com/

It's the best-looking website on the Bear Blog platform. No old junk, posts are short and everything is arranged with an almost offensive amount of taste. It turns out the CSS works exactly as advertised.

This raises serious questions about intellectual property, artistic integrity, and why nobody is paying me.

Free clown again.

This is how it starts. First they steal the CSS. Then they steal the website.

I have decided not to press charges.

And that was Karl's first post (archived):

Reset (2026-09-25 18:07)

I stumbled upon this post about Unstory, who is characterized as nihilistic, contemptuous, and often intellectually sloppy.

First off, brother from another mother. Any of that could've been written about me and the nonsense I write. Hell, I've been called those to my face.

Second, I shamelessly stole the theme. Fight me.

I've deleted all my old posts. It was time for a reset.

The "stolen" CSS theme, Unstory's link updating to Karl's new domain when he changed it (even though he'd stopped posting), and the edginess of Karl's early posts had me conclude Karl was a sockpuppet for Unstory, and I accused him of that in my email. He denied it, and I believe him.

Humans are inherently pattern-seeking creatures. It is a heuristic survival mechanism to connect dots that aren't there—to automatically assume the rustling grass is a terrifying man-eating beast and give us a few extra seconds of sprinting time.

But I'll admit I'm far more susceptible to this than the average person. I find myself only leaning more towards unfounded connections and significance—the so-called "synchronicity" that Jung underdeveloped.

A cursory glance at Karl's blog shows there were a handful of blog posts beforehand, demonstrating a different identity to Unstory.

The next morning my time—Nov. 21st, 2026 at 5:56 PM UTC—I realized the egg was on my face, and I sent him an apology:

Hey Karl,

I am sorry for the ad hominem in my previous email. I have no right to make a judgement call about your parenting, especially not being a parent myself.

You deserve to have the safety to feel comfortable of posting whatever you like on your blog.

I won't be bothering you again.

I was sincerely in the wrong, and I own up to that. And I thought that would be the end of that, but it wasn't.


What happened next involves Karl only indirectly—and part of it happened months before. On the evening of Nov. 20th, 2026, a reader saw our correspondence on bubbles.town and emailed me "Why this hate?" at 8:56 PM UTC. About ninety minutes later—Nov. 20th, 2026 at 10:20 PM UTC—this was posted in my guestbook:

Name: Marcus

lol indian fag sends hate mail. the irony. Your books suck.

I was a little surprised and upset by it, but you know, that's just how things are on the Internet. I'm desensitized to messages like this.

But after I sent my apology to Karl, I received another guestbook entry the next afternoon—Nov. 21st, 2026 at 8:23 PM UTC:

Name: Pietre

breaking news! gay dude larping as First Nations stalks people online.

This hurt a little more, as I've written about how Métis have had a massive Pretendian problem due to raceshifting, and have gone on record to share my own relations.

Anyways, my site uses Deflect.ca, so Netlify only records the CDN's IP address. After an earlier incident, I set up a function that logs the visitor IP (Deflect provides this in a True-Client-IP header) plus the user-agent on every guestbook submission.

Netlify Forms API output showing the two guestbook submissions: 'Marcus' (#5312, Nov. 20th, 2026 at 10:20 PM UTC) and 'Pietre' (#5363, Nov. 21st, 2026 at 8:23 PM UTC), with IP addresses and email redacted but identical Safari user-agent strings visible
The two submissions straight from the Netlify Forms API—IPs and email redacted; note the identical user-agent.
  • The "Marcus" message was sent from a residential fibre connection in Houston, Texas.
  • The "Pietre" message was sent from a commercial VPN exit in Toronto—but sent an identical user-agent header to "Marcus." The same version of Safari on a Mac, Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/605.1.15 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/26.6.2 Safari/605.1.15. The similarity of the messages, and use of a VPN here, are consistent with one person trying to cover their tracks.
Terminal output of the log-submission function showing the real visitor IP for the Pietre entry (partially redacted), followed by ipinfo.io lookups resolving to Houston, Texas and a Toronto VPN exit, plus the older lookup resolving to Marshall, Texas
The logged visitor IP for "Pietre," plus ipinfo lookups for all three known senders.

Hm, actually this reminded me of something, so I went and looked at older logs. There was another guestbook entry from a few months ago, on Aug. 19th, 2026 at 11:45 PM UTC (I posted a screenshot of it at the time) and it also came from another residential Texas address—Marshall, only two hours northeast of Houston:

Name: i am going to hurt you

you are a fag

Screenshot of my Netlify dashboard on mobile showing the August guestbook entry: the name 'i am going to hurt you' and the message 'you are a fag', received Aug. 19th, 2026 at 5:45 PM
The Aug. 19th, 2026 entry as it appeared in my Netlify dashboard, screenshotted at the time.

The IP on that one was disclosed by Deflect under a support ticket:

Screenshot of the Deflect support reply in Thunderbird (ticket #5947979, Aug. 20th, 2026): 'We have reviewed our logs concerning the reported incident. The actual IP address of the visitor who left the offensive review is', followed by the IP, redacted — also explaining that Deflect passes the real client IP in the True-Client-IP header
Deflect's support reply, disclosing the visitor's real IP (redacted).

This one was sent during the time when I was writing about Unstory, and when circlejerk.blog was parodying me, that linked post being written two days before I received the threat. Another coincidence.

And then I looked back further, and remembered I got yet another guestbook entry back on Apr. 11th, 2026 at 11:02 PM (Apr. 12th, 2026 at 5:02 AM UTC), before I had any logging set up:

Name: tmp

Dude, you're too into politics. Something about you being gay and then you call Calgary by its oonga boonga name and it's really off putting. You're getting into drama and such... why even keep doing this?

Screenshot of the Netlify form-notification email for the Apr. 11th, 2026 submission: sender 'brennan.day', name 'tmp', gibberish email cfdsfsd@gf.com, and the message about politics, being gay, and Calgary's name, received at 11:02 PM
The Netlify notification email for the Apr. 11th, 2026 submission.

I have no idea who sent that one, but there seems to be a pattern here, right?

In summary: four messages in seven months. Two of them—the threat from Aug. 19th, 2026 and "Marcus"—are from the same corner of east Texas, just a couple hours apart by car. The two this week share a user-agent string and were sent within a day of each other. Someone has been sending me slurs for months, long before Karl and I ever corresponded—I'm guessing his post gave them a new reason to write.

On Nov. 21st, 2026, after our email exchange, Karl wrote a post (archived) that ended with the line:

Oh, and for my rainbow indigenous friend, I’m adding an anime GIF.

Screenshot of Karl's post on householderkarl.com about anonymous online chess, ending with the line 'Oh, and for my rainbow indigenous friend, I'm adding an anime GIF'
Karl's post as it appeared on his blog, ending with the "rainbow indigenous" line.

The anime GIF is a callback to his reply, so I know the rainbow indigenous friend is, well, me.

Here's the deal. I don't believe Karl sent any of those guestbook entries. I have no proof, and I'd already burned my benefit of the doubt accusing him of being someone he's not.

What I believe is somebody who'd been sending me these messages for months saw my exchange with Karl and was reignited to harass me again. The overlap in phrasing—of my Queerness and ethnicity—is an unfortunate coincidence.

Four messages is a vanishingly small percentage of the correspondence I get—the overwhelming majority of people who write to me are kind, curious, and generous, and I'm extremely privileged that this is the worst I've had to deal with as someone who posts his face and yaps his opinions online nearly every day. Women get far worse than this for far less, often just for existing online. I document these entries because I think the pattern is worth noting, not because I'm claiming any suffering.

I'm sorry for what I wrote to Karl. I meant the apology I sent privately, and I mean this. Like everyone else, he should be able to post whatever he likes on his blog—including emails from correspondents—without getting undue criticism and insults from a neurotic, sanctimonious guy like me.

Publication Information

Title: An Open Apology to Householder Karl

Author: Brennan Kenneth Brown ORCID

Issue: #316 of brennan.day

License: CC BY-SA 4.0

Date Published:

Full URL: https://brennan.day/an-open-apology-to-householder-karl/

AT URI: at://did:plc:h4fm3emeptzegfs452eoiaz7/site.standard.document/3n2uwk6zvx62d

Place of Publication: Calgary, Alberta, Canada

Contact: mail@brennanbrown.ca

Cite this issue
  • MLA 9
    Brown, Brennan Kenneth. "An Open Apology to Householder Karl." brennan.day, 22 Nov. 2026, https://brennan.day/an-open-apology-to-householder-karl/.
  • APA 7
    Brown, B. K. (2026, November 22). An Open Apology to Householder Karl. brennan.day. https://brennan.day/an-open-apology-to-householder-karl/
  • Chicago (Notes-Bib)
    Brown, Brennan Kenneth. "An Open Apology to Householder Karl." brennan.day (blog). November 22, 2026. https://brennan.day/an-open-apology-to-householder-karl/.
  • BibTeX
    @online{brennan2026an-open-apology-to-householder-karl,
      author = {{Brown, Brennan Kenneth}},
      title = {{An Open Apology to Householder Karl}},
      year = {2026},
      url = {https://brennan.day/an-open-apology-to-householder-karl/},
      urldate = {2026-11-21}
    }

Comments

To comment, please sign in with your website:

How it works: Enter your website URL. IndieLogin signs you in through your site's IndieAuth server if it has one (e.g. indieauth.com), or checks your rel="me" links on GitHub, GitLab, Codeberg, and email. Setup instructions.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!


Webmentions

No webmentions yet. Be the first to send one!


Related Posts

↑ TOP